Explore Homes for Sale in St. Augustine, FL

St. Augustine, FL Homes for Sale: Explore Historic Charm & Coastal Living with Cindy Gavin Team

Looking for homes for sale in St. Augustine, FL? Discover a diverse array of properties in America's Oldest City, ranging from historic bungalows in Lincolnville to modern waterfront estates on Anastasia Island. St. Augustine offers an unparalleled lifestyle, blending rich history, vibrant culture, and stunning natural beauty. From the cobbled streets of the Historic District to the pristine beaches, finding your ideal property here is an exciting journey. The Cindy Gavin Team provides expert guidance through the unique St. Augustine real estate market, helping you explore the perfect home that fits your unique aspirations and lifestyle.

Get New St. Augustine Listings Before They Hit Zillow

The best homes move fast. See them first.

See Homes Before Everyone Else

St. Augustine Real Estate Map Search

The Allure of St. Augustine Real Estate

As you consider relocating or investing, St. Augustine, FL, presents a unique proposition for those seeking homes for sale. This enchanting city, celebrated for its rich history and stunning coastal landscapes, offers more than just a place to live; it provides a lifestyle. From its iconic Castillo de San Marcos to the sun-kissed sands of St. Augustine Beach, every corner whispers tales of centuries past while embracing modern amenities.

Diverse St. Augustine Homes for Sale

Delving deeper into the market reveals an extensive range of homes for sale, catering to various tastes and budgets. The city's unique geography and historical development have cultivated a property landscape as varied as its residents.

Historic District & Downtown Homes

For those drawn to old-world charm, homes for sale within St. Augustine's Historic District, particularly in areas like Lincolnville and near Flagler College, offer a chance to own a piece of history. Discover beautifully preserved Victorian homes, charming bungalows, and Spanish Colonial revival residences. These properties provide walkability to vibrant shops, acclaimed restaurants, and significant historical sites, making them highly sought after.

Coastal & Waterfront Properties

The allure of the Atlantic Ocean defines another significant segment of St. Augustine real estate. Homes for sale on Anastasia Island, including St. Augustine Beach and Crescent Beach, offer direct oceanfront access or proximity to the Intracoastal Waterway. Here, you'll find everything from luxurious oceanfront estates and modern single-family homes to convenient condos offering stunning views and direct beach access. Vilano Beach also presents unique waterfront options with a quaint, artistic vibe.

Family-Friendly Neighborhoods & Suburbs

Beyond the historic core and beaches, St. Augustine boasts numerous family-oriented communities. Neighborhoods like World Golf Village, Southwoods, and areas within the renowned St. Johns County school district offer a different style of homes for sale. Expect master-planned communities with ample amenities, newer construction, larger lots, and a quieter suburban atmosphere, providing excellent options for growing families or those seeking a more tranquil setting. Communities like Nocatee, while technically in St. Johns County, are popular choices for those seeking proximity to St. Augustine's amenities with a focus on new builds and modern living.

Unique Property Types & Investment Opportunities

The St. Augustine market also includes various other homes for sale, such as townhomes, villas, and vacant land, presenting opportunities for custom builds or investment. Whether seeking a seasonal retreat, a rental income property, or a plot to realize your dream home, the diversity here is impressive.

Lifestyle & Amenities for St. Augustine Homeowners

Beyond the homes themselves, St. Augustine promises an enriching lifestyle. Homeowners enjoy unparalleled access to cultural landmarks such as the Lightner Museum and the Colonial Quarter. The city's thriving culinary scene offers everything from upscale dining to casual beachfront cafes. Outdoor enthusiasts will appreciate the endless opportunities for boating, fishing, kayaking, and golf, with numerous courses like St. Johns Golf & Country Club nearby. The excellent St. Johns County schools also make it a prime location for families.

Navigating the St. Augustine Real Estate Market

When exploring homes for sale in St. Augustine, understanding the nuances of this dynamic market is crucial. Property values can vary significantly based on location, historical significance, and proximity to water. The Cindy Gavin Team brings unparalleled local expertise to help you navigate these complexities. We are dedicated to understanding your unique needs and connecting you with properties that truly embody your vision of St. Augustine living. Let us guide you through finding your ideal home in this captivating city.

Newest Homes for Sale in St. Augustine, FL

$5,974,000
2141314 MLS
This 8.36 acre site has approximately 684 Front Footage on SR 16. No other listed properties in the immediate market area comes close!! Site is in the process of being planned and permitted for potential entitlements up to 70,000 sqft. Virtually all of SR 16 has become a High Demand/High Traffic Area with this section generating 43,000+ AADT per the 2024 study. The majority of sites available two years ago are now in some phase of site plan approval, preclosing or vertical construction. Note: there is a Median Cut already in place on 16 going directly in front of the driveway. This of course is Huge as it provides easy access for customers going in either direction. The way the site plan is laid out now demonstrates that there would be two buildable sites on each side of the drive fronting SR 16. The site East of the drive would be 2.1 acres fronting 16 plus a .43 ac share in the retention for a total of 2.53 acres. Please Click More for further details The site West of the drive would be 3.29 ac frontage, plus .69 ac share of retention, totaling 3.98 ac. Additionally, in back of the East 2.1 ac site sits a 1.53 ac site that can accommodate up to an 18K square foot, 5 story structure. As per the site plan the 1.44 acre retention pond is situated in back of the West 3.29 ac site. Your clients can purchase the full 8.36 acres, the 2.53 ac site on the East side of the drive, or the 3.98 ac site on the W. side of the drive. Any which way you slice it your client can not possibly get better exposure than these sites afford. note: the 1900 and the 1910 SR 16 listings are the same parcel of land with different approaches as to how the 8.35 acres are marketed & or developed. Pricing breakdown for different purchase options as follows: Option 1: Purchase the entire 8.36 acre site for $5,974,000 (parcel numbers 1-4 on site map) as per this 1900 SR 16 Listing. Option 2: Purchase the smaller 2.53 ac site E. of the drive (parcel 2) for $2.2M (acreage includes the E. 1/2 of driveway and a .43 ac interest in the retention) per 1910 Listing Option 3: Purchase the larger 3.98 ac site W. of the drive (parcel 1) for $4M (acreage includes the W 1/2 of driveway and a .69 ac interest in the retention pond) Please note this site W of the drive has two businesses on it which generates income. Option 4: Add parcel 4 on site map to option 2 or 3 for $500K. Parcel #4 is 1.53 ac plus a .32ac for retention (1.85 total). Examples are detailed below. Adding parcel 4 to option 2 would change price from $2.2 to $2.7. Acreage would go from 2.53 to 4.38. (2.53 + 1.8 acres) Adding parcel 4 to option 3 would change price from $4M to $4.5M. Acreage would go from 3.98 to 5.83. (3.98 + 1.85 = 5.83 ac) In a recent review there were only two other parcels with 5 or more acres available in the immediate market area. One had 200 ft Frontage, and the other 225 (as expected, both of those have gone under contract). The attached engineer generated site plan can be developed as shown or in most cases reconfigured to meet the developers vision and needs. All front footages and acreage estimates are based on measurements per the tax roll and other undocumented sources. It is fully the purchasers responsibility to confirm any and all estimates, approximations, calculations or assumptions. Virtually all of SR 16 has become a High Demand/High Traffic Area. Per the traffic count attachments, the AADT in this section of SR 16 was 43,000 per the 2024 update. This of course was before the 4 large rental communities came on line. The vast majority of sites previously available two and a half years ago are now in some phase of site plan approval, preparation for closing or physical site construction. 3 of the 4 new housing projects in the area have come Directly to 16 (please see pics regarding location of these developments). The upscale Tapestry located just to the W. of this site finished construction several months ago and should be nearing stabilization of 300+ units. Gatlin Development just completed another 300+ units in the 1100 block of SR 16 and is leasing. Madison Street started construction of 232 units last April in the 800 to 900 block of 16. The fourth large housing development (Terrassa w 300+ units) is just North of 16 and E. of I-95 where the mall used to be. Clearly this high growth area is in need of commercial retail and services to satisfy the Mushrooming demand. Other commercial (non-residential) projects recently built on 16 include a top end used car dealership (Sunday Drive) which opened in the 2100 blk and the HCA Healthcare Emergency clinic opened at the location previously know as 890 SR 16. In the coming soon category there is a dental bldg w a coffee shop at 45 Village Crossing Ct. formerly know as 840 SR 16, Atlantic Marine is planning a new boat showroom in the 2200 blk., plus a 7-11 with pumps is making plans to open next year close to the boat showroom. This 8.3 acre site is in the process of being planned and permitted for potential entitlements up to 70,000 sqft. This site is especially geared for the developer and end user looking to take maximum advantage of the top end traffic count of 43K/day and growing(see attachment line 93.2). Very Important to note that there is a Median Cut already in place on 16 going directly into the drive providing easy access for customers going in either direction. Any way you slice it, your client can't possibly get better exposure than this site than this site affords. Sites will be ideal for developers or clients looking to build structures in the 7 to 10,000 foot per acre range. Check attached Zoning charts to confirm your project applies. Although this property has a 3000 ft metal structure & two businesses on site W. of the drive, they are not necessarily being considered in the valuation of this property. The two businesses are Auto Repair and Used Auto Sales. Zoning in the front portion of this overall site is Commercial Intensive (CI), however purchaser must confirm zoning and all other pertinent details for themselves and not rely solely on information contained herein. IT IS VERY IMPORTANT THAT THE TENANT IS NOT DISTURBED! Listed below is a partial list of commercial businesses that could do very well at this site which certainly includes Auto Dealerships!! Convenience stores w gas pumps like Gate, Raceway, Marathon or Buc-ee's. Other fits are grocers like Trader Joe's, Sprouts, Fresh Market or Fitness Studios. QSR's (quick serve restaurants) like Five Guys, Cava, BurgerFi or Panda Express, Drive-Thru coffee & Beverage Shops like Dutch Brothers or Ellianos, Banks-Credit Unions, Urgent Care/Medical Office/Vision Care i.e. America's Best Contacts, or Dental like Heartland or Deca Dental. Also needed is a Pharmacy w Drive-Thru. Specialty Retail like Mattress Firm, Auto Zone, O'Reilly's or Wireless Providers. Car washes like Mr. Clean, Tommy's Tidal Wave or Mister Car Wash.

1900 State Road 16 Street, St. Augustine

Start Your Search
© 2026 Northeast Florida Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved. This data is up-to-date as of . For the most current information, contact Real Estate Company.